AI and Avodah Zarah: A Torah-based Discussion of Artificial Intelligence

Find it here…

Participant Panelists: Dr. David Manheim, Dr. Michael G. Samet, Rabbi Arnie Wittenstein, Rabbi Boruch Clinton, & Rabbi Daniel Freedman
Moderator: Rabbi Reuven Subar

Abstract:
This moderated discussion explores various Torah-based viewpoints related to AI (Artificial Intelligence). In this video, AI experts and learned rabbinic scholars engage in a thought-provoking conversation that probes the potential implications of AI. The esteemed panelists discussed the state of generative AI technology, its current limitations, and how it differs from earlier technology, while also generally talking about their backgrounds and interests in AI.
The panelists also focused on the potential risks of relying on AI for decision-making and other ethical issues. In doing so, they considered how AI technology may or may not resemble the Jewish struggle against paganism/idolatry (both being man-made and sometimes ascribed autonomous power). The panelists further touched on the challenges of integrating AI into everyday Jewish life, such as the possible uses of AI tech for rendering Halachic decisions and the betterment of Jewish society (e.g., to assist in making shidduchim). Overall, the participants shared their insights and conclusions on the implications of AI for religion and society as a whole, and answered questions from the live Zoom audience.

Panelist Bios:
Dr. David Manheim is the director of policy and research at the think-tank Association for Long Term Existence and Resilience (ALTER) in Israel, which focuses on the risks and benefits of future technology. He is currently a visiting researcher at the Technion University, where he studies biological and technological risks and the impacts of new technologies.

Dr. Michael G. Samet is a veteran of the machine-learning industry and in that capacity has been involved in the fields of military, health, and academia in developing such systems. He is the brother of Rabbi Yehuda Samet (Mashgiach of Yeshivat Ohr Somayach in Jerusalem) and father-in-law of Rabbi Rabbi Zvi Sobolofsky (a Rosh Yeshiva at Yeshiva University).

Rabbi Arnie Wittenstein is the son of legendary NASA physicist Jerry (Gerald) Wittenstein. He is currently a fellow at the Kollel of Yeshivas Mir in Jerusalem and serves as an educator at Yeshivat Torat Shraga in Jerusalem. His widely acclaimed lectures are available online and through his podcast, Jewish History Uncensored. He dabbled in computer programming during the 1970s and 1980s.

Rabbi Boruch Clinton is a long-time Judaic educator in Yeshivot and Beis Yaakov institutes in Toronto. He has also written numerous books on Torah-oriented topics and on technology, including the Linux Bible. Professionally, he works as a Linux server admin and AWS solutions architect. He also writes the B’chol D’rachecha publication on Substack.

Rabbi Daniel Freedman holds a BA from WITS University in his native South Africa (with a special focus on history, political science, and philosophy) and a BA in Talmudic Law from the Hertz Institute Teacher Training College of Ohr Lagolah in Jerusalem, Israel. He has more than two decades of experience as a web developer, and is currently employed by an Israeli startup that is developing a digital medical referral system.

How to Browse Mizrachi Torah Publications: A Simple Life Tip

I occasionally come across so-called low-grade “Religious Zionist” print publications I suspect conceal some Torah truths but whose pictures are inappropriate.

You think you can copy Rabbi Meir studying from Acher?

Here’s a solution: Skim the titles in a dark room. You will quickly see if there is anything to be gained (usually not!), and avoid unseemly sights.

Don’t laugh!

Make Galus Great Again – A Funny Perspective on Trump Troubles

I thought you might enjoy a comment conversation I read…

Paul D. Van Pelt:

So, it has led us up to this. We are so pregnant with pause, we can scarcely stand it. Playing into the narcissism of the subject is the object of his interest, preference and motive. I would PREFER he not be patronized. No arrest. No attention. No anything. It may not play that way. However, anyone who has followed the strategy of this subject ought to know his MO by now. Everything done plays into his artful dodger personna. I have a different proposal. Deport him. Declare him a public nuisance; threat to national security; advocate of sedition. Other undesirable people have been dealt with, for, arguably less damning reasonings. Or, allegations.
Or, insinuations. Come on now. What is the law? Damned good question.

Christopher (blog owner):

Europe eventually did get rid of Napoleon, with the combined work of the British Navy, the Russian winter, Iberian guerilla warfare, Metternichian diplomacy, and Talleyrandian duplicity. It took a lot. And some Prussians who arrived at Waterloo in the nick of time. But I like the image. Mar-a-Lago is Elba. The 100 days ending with Waterloo are still ahead of us…

Paul D. Van Pelt:

Thanks, Christopher. This is not for you only. It is for everyone wondering how the opera plays out. Today, I parsed things as best I can. No one wants another black eye from history. Well, not free world nations, anyway. I reassert we are expending too much money/time/distress on disposing of an annoyance. He may be a little nervous now, but he is still laughing. There was a maxim in administrative law, something called a totality of circumstances. This recognizes that, yes, some cases are egregious and, facially, worthy of pursuit, but what will the outcome obtain, against the expenditure of time/money? We are not batting well right now. You got my comparison with Napoleon. There is nothing that can be done with the subject now that would measurably improve or embellish American history. The narcissist knows this. That is why he is laughing.

Read the rest here…


Do I agree? I don’t know and I don’t care.