A Political Loyalty Pledge (Intriguing Proposal by Mordechai Sones!)

No Signature, No Vote

A vote only for a signature: how to stop handing our votes to lists that break their word, and how to make even an abstention count

A week ago I wrote about a question on which I differ, with great respect, from rabbis I admire: whether voting in Israel’s elections is a mitzvah. I called on our communities to withhold their votes publicly and visibly. Since then, readers have been asking me the obvious next question: how? Here is my answer: stop giving the vote away for free.

Give it only to a list that commits in writing, before the election, to three conditions, and makes that commitment before a beit din it does not pay and cannot appoint. A list that does not sign does not get the vote. A list that signs and breaks its word never gets it again.

That is the whole idea. Below is why it is needed, how it works, what the halacha says, and the objections I have heard, with my answers. Signing opens after a legal review, and the last section explains why and how you can help.

What a vote buys today

A vote no longer decides what will be done. Since the 1990s, more and more of that power has passed to the court, the legal advisers, the General Staff and Washington. On January 1, 2024, the High Court struck down an amendment to a Basic Law: the only part of the elected coalition’s judicial overhaul that had become law.

What a vote still gives is a seal of approval. After the election, the world, the court, the army and the nation are told: the public chose this. From then on, whatever is done has been “decided by Israel.”

And a vote that is guaranteed in advance is worth nothing to a party. When the religious-Zionist public is told that voting is an absolute obligation, its vote belongs to a list before the campaign opens. No party pays for what it already owns. The list-makers know where those votes will go, whatever they do about Homesh or Hebron.

A vote is worth something only while it can be withheld. The pledge gives it back that value: it is given only in return for a signature.

The record

Eight times since 1977, a leader the right-wing public had elected promised one thing and then did the opposite. The other rows below are not promises broken, but they show the same thing: what the vote was cast for, and what it bought.

Continue reading on Jewish Home News here…