Falsus in Numeris: Government Lies About Inflation, Unemployment, Whatnot

Newsflash: Governments Lie

08/12/2025

Bureau of Labor Statistics head Dr. Erika McEntarfer is one of the latest persons President Trump has told “you’re fired.” President Trump said this month that he fired Dr. McEntarfer because the president believed she manipulated jobs data. Manipulations, he stated, include the updated May and June BLS numbers showing the U.S. economy created 258,000 fewer jobs than originally reported, as well as the weaker than expected July jobs report. All of this, the president suggested, was designed to make President Trump look bad.

Following Dr. McEntarfer’s firing, many commenters worried that President Trump’s actions would create the perception that government unemployment and inflation data is manipulated to produce the numbers desired by the president. A loss of confidence in government statistics could impact demand for US Treasuries. This is because the value of Treasuries is adjusted based on the BLS-issued Consumer Price Index (CPI). If investors don’t trust the CPI figures, they can demand higher returns, increasing government’s interest payments.

President Trump is correct that BLS manipulates statistics related to the economy, but it has been doing so since long before Donald Trump moved to the White House.

For example, starting in 1994, the BLS stopped including “discouraged” workers who have stopped looking for work in the official unemployment figures. The BLS also includes those working part-time as employed even if the only reason they are working part-time is they cannot find full-time work. According to John Williams, publisher of the website Shadow Stats, including discouraged and part-time workers who want full-time work in the unemployment figures increases the unemployment rate by almost 20 percent!

The government also understates the effects of inflation. One way it does this is by using “chained CPI.” Chained CPI means that even if price inflation has made steak unaffordable for most Americans, the government does not consider their standard of living lowered if they can buy a “substitute” such as hamburger.

This ignores the fact that if consumers viewed hamburger and steak as equivalent then they would likely have chosen cheaper hamburger before Federal Reserve-caused price inflation made steak unaffordable, leaving them no choice but to purchase hamburger. According to John Williams’s Shadow Stats, using a more accurate definition of inflation would increase the inflation rate to as much as 12 percent.

Manipulating the unemployment and inflation rates allows the government to gaslight the people into believing that the economy is strong and any signs of weakness — such as rising prices or an increase in unemployment in their town — are anomalies that do not reflect the economy’s real condition. Manipulating the inflation figures to understate the true amount of inflation also lowers the “cost of living” increases the government must provide for veterans, beneficiaries of Social Security, and others. This provides a way for government to cut spending without Congress members having politically difficult votes.

President Trump has done a service by highlighting that government statistics regarding the economy are manipulated. Many of those criticizing President Trump for endangering the “credibility” of government’s inflation and unemployment numbers are either unaware of, or more likely have no problem with, manipulating data to fool the public into thinking the welfare-warfare system and the fiat money system are “working.” They only object to manipulating the data to benefit President Trump. President Trump should ensure the government’s unemployment and inflation figures are as accurate as possible by appointing John Williams of Shadow Stats to head the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

From Mises.org, here.

Rabbi Dov Fischer Thanks Hashem For All the Good! (reprinted with assumed permission)

As We Emerge from The Nine Days, Please Forgive Me for Being Thankful for the Good

As we emerge from the days when we commemorate millennia of terrible tragedy, I remind us that there are good things happening, because we must gain strength from them to be able to survive the bad.

As we emerge from the days when we commemorate millennia of terrible tragedy, I remind us that there are good things happening, too. Miracles upon miracles. Amid all the problems — European static and pointless and meaningless threats to recognize an Arab country in Israel, Mamdani in New York City, the Great Hamas Famine Hoax — can we pause for a moment, amid the month of Av, to celebrate some of what is good?

No, do not forget to cry over the above aspects of aggravation, such as the way that Hamas and the anti-Israel media and left-wing countries have manipulated a narrative that blames Israel for humanitarian issues that are not of its doing. And yes, by all means, continue to kvetch about more minor issues. But . . .  several Sinwars are dead. And a Jewish girl who was an inch or millimeter away from being massacred and worse only 18 months ago came in second place on an international song stage in Europe that tried to ban her because she is Israeli. She stared down a continent full of antisemites while projecting Jewish pride and being normal. And even if there are halakhic issues regarding standards of modesty and a woman’s singing voice, she is a heroine for just daring to represent Israel and the Jewish people in the face of haters wanting to finish what Hamas started.

Celebrate that.

HaRav Avigdor Miller zt”l once celebrated life by saying: “Most people look at a glass partially filled with water and see it either half-empty or half-full. However, I see it completely full: half with water and half with Hashem’s life-preserving oxygen.” (And some kvetcher will write back that the oxygen is only 21 percent of the air.) So please forgive me for celebrating these aspects of the past year or two, which I will refer to as “THEN” and “NOW”:

  1. THEN: We were facing 150,000 Hezbollah precision missiles and thousands of armed fighters organized in units like their Radwan Force. Retired General Itzhak Brick was on TV and in print with a weekly front-page Jeremiad in the Israeli daily, Maariv, predicting Doom and Destruction.

NOW: Their missiles are mostly all gone. From Fuad Shukr to Nasrallah and more, all their leaders are evaporated, like in the song “Ya Ya Nasrallah.” Thousands of their fighters either lost their hips and reproductive organs or their hands and eyes from pagers and walkie-talkies, so are retired from fighting. Hezbollah’s patron, Assad, was ousted from Syria, and so are they. That’s good, no?

  1. THEN: Hamas was ruling, and Gaza was bustling. Every single day, rockets were fired into Ashkelon, Ashdod, Sderot. Incendiary balloons wiped out Israeli forests daily — for years — and all Israeli bombast could not stop it. Everyone was terrified to send ground troops in because the Gazans live in teeming “refugee camps,” on top of each other, with snipers in every window, and any ground invasion would see our boys massacred day after day in the tens of thousands.

NOW: Most of Gaza is flattened like the Flintstones’ Bedrock, and a new offensive may very well finalize the pancaking of Gaza. The IDF craters may give rise to a new form of “Street Golf” for tourists in Trump’s Gaza Shangri-la; they now have the holes and the sand traps. Rafiach (Rafah) is being cut off, Herzi Halevy is out, Gallant is out, and the end may be in sight.

The American president has lifted the Biden-Harris-Blinken embargoes and told everyone to unleash hell. Hillary, Kerry, Tillerson, and Blinken are replaced by Rubio. Likewise, Indyk, Kurtzer, Nides, and Lew are replaced by Huckabee. Austin is replaced by Hegseth. Biden and Harris are replaced by Trump. Mohammed Deif is dead, Yahya Sinwar is dead, Ismail Haniyeh is dead.

And the world has no remaining enforcement tools against Israel because (i) they already have issued arrest warrants which have added up to nothing, and (ii) declared “genocide,” which leaves them nothing else. America does not recognize the ICJ or ICC, and that’s enough. Nor do we need Netanyahu traveling to Italy, Spain, or France. Better that he stay home and focus on finishing with Gaza and keeping the new lid on Iran.

  1. THEN: the International Court of Justice issued arrest warrants against Prime Minister Netanyahu and Defense Minister Gallant, and the International Criminal Court found Israel guilty of war crimes and genocide.

NOW: We have seen it means nothing.

NOW: We have new friends: Hungary, which then helped murder 800,000 Jews in 1944, but now has an amazingly pro-Israel leader in Victor Orban, who defied the ICC and ICJ, and hosted Netanyahu on a red carpet and along the Danube. Argentina, which once was the haven for Hitler’s Nazis up to Mengele and Eichmann, now has the most pro-Israel leader in the entire world, Javier Milei, who (truly) is better on Israel than any Reform rabbi and may even convert to Chabad when he retires from politics. Geert Wilders in Holland. Friedrich Mertz, the guy in Germany is an improvement. So is Bart DeWever, newly elected in Belgium. All improvements for Israel, conservatives replacing global leftists. Even the guy in El Salvador is pro-Israel.

  1. THEN: Assad hosted Hamas, Iran, and Putin. Iran smuggled resupplies to Lebanon through Syria. While new headaches are on the way with the new ISIS guy and Erdogan, that’s for tomorrow, and it is bringing even the anti-Israel Syrian Druze closer to Israel (the ones in Israel are patriots in the army).

NOW: Hamas is ousted from Syria. Also Iran. Putin has had to move his entire Syrian apparatus to Libya. Israel has done so much damage to Syria’s air defenses, and Putin is so out of Syria that those air lanes have been open to Iran.

  1. THEN: The Houthis came outta nowhere and became a menace that Biden and Harris allowed to take root.

NOW: With the obliteration of their international airport (despite their claims it is up and running) and key ports and cement factories, it is incontrovertible that the only reason they still exist is that Israel refuses to obliterate their electricity, fuel, communications, and water systems. Clearly, after taking out the international airport in 15 minutes, Israel has revealed she can take out the whole place. The rest of the world would condemn but secretly cheer, as when Begin took out Saddam’s nukes. The Houthi menace is only as much a threat as Israel allows it to be.

  1. THEN: Biden reversed all of Trump’s sanctions and Made Iran Lethal Again. Kamala Harris, a pure idiot, was promising a “Two State Solution” while giving a million dollars to Oprah’s production company, a million to Al Sharpton, a million to Beyonce, buying endorsements at one million a clip, and not quite clear which two states she was talking about.

Josh Shapiro reversed 30 years of his documented strong Zionism and opposition to a “Two State Solution,” dating back to his proud college days, just to mollify the Woke and beg his way onto the Harris ticket.

NOW: Harris and Walz are forgotten (except for this brief reminder). Her cackling no longer blares in our ears. Biden is lost, and his own party leaders mock him daily and deny they said he was sane. Trump has reinstated the Iran sanctions even heavier. Iran has lost almost their entire Russian-made air defenses and 80 percent or more of their capabilities to manufacture ballistic missiles. Their nuclear program has been set back by years. Fordow was obliterated, as were the others. Really, the “shulchan” is “arukh”:  With or without Trump, the table is all set. And, while the peripatetic Trump makes everyone around him meshuggah, the Obama JCPOA, revived by Biden, will not be Trump’s legacy. The resolution of Iran’s nukes was inconceivable even six months ago.

  1. THEN: Since 1948, and even more since 1967, and especially since Oslo 1993, Israel has always been pocked by sizable numbers of foreign-funded (Europe, Soros, Reform Judaism) leftists agitating to hand over half the country, from the River to the Sea, to Arafat, Abbas, and any other Arab who will bomb them and cut their throats. Active Prime Minister candidates actually once included near-saboteurs like Ehud Olmert and Ehud Barak, each of whom caught Arafat off-guard by offering him more than he asked for.  Yair Lapid, Israel’s shortest-serving Prime Minister (only six months longer than you), won 24 seats to head the Opposition.

NOW: Over 80 percent of the Israeli public and Knesset seats are determined never to allow an Arab sovereign ever to arise between the River and the Sea. An actual Knesset vote of 71-13 declared Judea and Samaria ripe for annexation. Some 80 percent have declared, 30 years after Oslo, that Judea and Samaria no longer are on the table for Arab sovereignty. That ship has sailed. Abbas (age 89½) soon will be dead, one way or another, and then Hamas will formally gain control of Judea and Samaria, which will leave the likes of Macron, Keir Starmer, and Josh Shapiro befuddled while it will open a golden opportunity to finish flattening the Arab entity there, as now is underway in Jenin. It is just a bit more time until reality sets in: A new Arab country, if created within Israel, would be led by the same Hamas that has turned Gaza into . . . Gaza.

Despite Lapid’s emaciated Yesh Atid, the Marxist-oriented Labor and Meretz (“Democrats”) extremists, and the ten Knesset Arabs, some 80 percent of Israel’s present and next governments are firmly on record that they will permanently hold Judea and Samaria, either by annexation or permanent military suzerainty. (Learn that word. It is coming soon. Remember: You heard it first here: Israeli suzerainty over Judea and Samaria.) Benny Gantz has transitioned to Judea-Samaria permanence. Bennett, who cannot be trusted, nevertheless will not cross that red line either. Liberman lives there, and it’s all about him.

After Hamas replaces Mahmoud Abbas — age 89.5, so will die sooner than later, even if not assassinated by Hamas — Judea-Samaria becomes “game-set-match.” For the rest of time, the debate will be between “annexation / reunification” and “permanent security presence / occupation / suzerainty.” The Arabs, before our very eyes, shuffled themselves out of their phony “Palestine.” Meanwhile, nearly one million Jews now live in the eastern districts of United Jerusalem and the remainder of Judea and Samaria — 100 times the population of Gush Katif, too many to uproot, relocate, educate and employ elsewhere. “Palestine” is over. Macron does not matter. It is one thing to say it in France or at the United Nations. Another thing to matter. Look up “Count Folke Bernadotte.” He also declared an Arab country in Israel. Yitzchak Shamir disagreed with him.

  1. THEN: The American colleges and universities all were pocked with tent encampments. Jewish kids were afraid. Student bodies were teeming with foreign-born Arab Muslims financed by Arab Muslim countries studying under foreign-born Arab Muslim professors dedicated to overthrowing America and destroying Israel.

NOW: Fewer than eight or so campuses among hundreds have had small one-day eruptions this past year, and Rubio, Tom Homan, and Kristi Noem have Trump’s green light to throw them all out. The haters are scared. They wear masks, whether keffiyes or N95’s, not for Arab solidarity but terrified of detection, while schools and cities are banning the masks under old KKK laws. Last year’s cowardly college deans now call in the cops to arrest the mongrels, and the cops remove the masks, take permanent mug shots and fingerprints, and share with ICE. Even better, Trump is now nailing them down, campus by campus. Columbia just gave up and agreed to pay $220 million and adopt a host of Trump-demanded changes. The others are watching Harvard to see whether their confrontational approach is better. Even they are changing their atmosphere, but they are in for more.

The befuddled mongrels now are so off balance that, instead of protesting for their original vulgar cause “From the River to the Sea,” they now focus all demands on getting last year’s mongrels released from prison before they are shipped off to El Salvador, Libya, Somalia, or where they came from.

Trump has cut $1 billion from Cornell, $2.2 billion — and more — from Harvard, and those moral cesspools all are beginning to see the light. It turns out that Jews are not the only people on earth who care about money.

So I am grateful. It is like the last sugya (segment) of Mesekhet (Tractate) Makkot at folio 24. Other sagacious rabbis saw foxes roaming on the holy Temple Mount and wept, but Rabbi Akiva found reason to be positive. He said that if the Bible’s severe warning came true, that one day the Temple Mount would be degraded to being a sanctuary for foxes, then he was certain that the other Biblical prophecy also would come true: that, one day, Mount Zion would be restored and the Temple rebuilt.

There is always good reason to kvetch. But please forgive me for being grateful to Hashem and his messengers on earth for all the good…

Subscribe to Rav Fischer’s YouTube channel here at bit.ly/3REFTbk and follow him on X (Twitter) at @DovFischerRabbi to find his latest classes, interviews, speeches, and observations.

To attend any of his three weekly Zoom classes — Sundays on the past week’s events impacting Israel and world Jewry, and Tuesdays and Thursdays on the Tanakh (Bible) and Jewish law — send a request to rabbi@yioc.org

Readers’ Comments:  https://www.israelnationalnews.com/news/408398

NACHAMU: While We Cry We Smile

URI DAVIDI – We Will Sing Again (Acapella) | אורי דוידי

Listen on YT…

Lyrics

Marching by the river banks of Babylon
Exiled from our land, the glory that has gone
What the future’s gonna be, no one can say
Crying bitterly as we look behind
Knowing what we’ve lost, but not what we will find
Holding our harps so tight, on our way

But while we cry we smile, our song lives on
For we knew

That we will sing again
They will hear us far and wide
We will sing again
We won’t cast the harp aside
From afar gathering
In a chorus that will ring
Oh, We will sing again
Walking through our lives
we shed so many tears
Challenges we meet, our sorrows and our fears
Yet we know tomorrow , there’ll be reason to sing
So we keep alive the legacy of old
The music of the past echoes in our souls
We will always have our faith through everything

But while we cry we smile, our song lives on
For we know

That we will sing again
There will always be a time
We will sing again
And the light of old will shine
It’ll be very soon
Every heart will play that tune
Oh, we will sing again

Rabbi Shalom Ber Sorotzkin’s Stirring Pledge to Talmidim Amidst Regime’s Threats

Rav Shalom Ber Sorotzkin Delivers Stirring Address: “We’re Facing a Difficult Time – But We Can Embrace It with Elevation”

August 4, 20257:15 pm

At the conclusion of the summer zman, the rosh yeshiva of Ateres Shlomo, Rav Shalom Ber Sorotzkin, delivered a powerful and emotionally charged shmuess to hundreds of talmidim in the yeshiva’s main beis medrash in Rishon LeTzion. In his remarks, Rav Sorotzkin addressed the current climate of personal and financial sanctions being threatened against bnei Torah and called on his talmidim to face the challenge with inner greatness and unwavering emunah.

“We are entering a difficult and complex period,” the rosh yeshiva said, “and we can’t pretend otherwise. But if we approach it correctly, we can carry it with romemus—elevation—and leitzanusa de’avodah zarah—mockery of idolatry. They speak of ‘personal sanctions,’ ‘economic sanctions,’ as if we’re dependent on them. But they have no power over us. The Creator of all worlds chose us, crowned us as princes in His kingdom. We know the truth—banu bachar Hashem. We are not afraid, because we know Who runs the world.”

Rav Sorotzkin emphasized that this is a unique test for bnei yeshiva in our generation. “Hashem says about you, ‘Chazu chazu banei chavivai’—look at My precious sons. Hashem chose you, even if it comes with some ‘avodas perach’. From all generations, He chose us for this task. He showers us with a special love. I bring you close, you are the ministers in Hashem’s kingdom.”

He urged his talmidim to recognize their inner greatness and responsibility. “We need to know who we are, and understand that everything hinges on us. Everything depends on the shtender. There is no power like it. Every single minute of Torah transforms the world. Billions of people don’t possess the strength of one minute of Torah—we do.”

Rav Sorotzkin shared a story of a recent event he was invited to in the U.S., only to realize upon arrival that it was a public debate on the draft. A traditional Jew, not aligned with the Torah world, began using familiar catchphrases: “equality of burden,” “mutual responsibility.” Rav Sorotzkin replied: “I’m not going to debate you on the worldview of our gedolim—but tell me, do you believe in the Divine origin of Torah? He answered yes.”

“I asked him: Yaakov Avinu said he conquered Shechem ‘with my sword and bow’—but he never fought there! Everyone knows it was Shimon and Levi who attacked. So how can Yaakov say he did it? Rashi says, ‘With my prayers and supplications.’ The battle was spiritually won by Yaakov, even if he wasn’t physically present. Why aren’t Shimon and Levi mentioned? Because ultimately, what determines victory on the battlefield is tefillah and Torah. Hishtadlus is necessary—but it’s only a façade. The real result is decided solely by Hashem, and through tzlusi uva’usi.”

Victory, Rav Sorotzkin said, depends on Klal Yisrael looking heavenward. “When, Heaven forbid, our brothers fall in battle—it’s when there’s a weakness in Yisrael mistaklim klapei maalah. The reduction in Torah learning is what causes the fall—Hashem yerachem.”

He continued: “They tell us, ‘economic sanctions’—what will be? Let me say clearly, and I’ve said it in the dining room before and I’ll say it again: I am not responsible for all of Klal Yisrael, but I take responsibility for each and every one of you—my beloved talmidim and alumni. Whatever the issue, in any area, b’ezras Hashem, I will be there for you. You have nothing to worry about—remove the burden from your hearts.”

Rav Sorotzkin shared an encounter with a wealthy individual who questioned why he should give so much money to Torah. “I told him what the Moreh Nevuchim says—if a massive bridge was built by thousands of non-Jews over decades, was it not ultimately built for Torah? The Moreh Nevuchim says it was. Even if a Jew learns five minutes of Torah on that bridge—that’s the purpose for which it exists.”

“I asked him—so you believe the bridge was built for Torah, but you don’t believe that global business in Manhattan revolves around Torah? Everything you do, every mission Hashem gave you—it’s all for Torah.”

Addressing the threats against the Torah world, Rav Sorotzkin quoted the Rambam at the end of Hilchos Shemitah V’Yovel and Rashi in Shabbos, explaining that someone whose sole occupation is Torah is promised livelihood by Hashem, like the Kohanim who were supported chalef avodasam. “Hashem will provide for the amelei Torah directly—this is His promise.”

He added: “There are people who receive parnassah through their work, through their effort. But the Rambam teaches that those who learn Torah receive directly from Hashem. We are not dependent on you—Hashem has provided for us, provides for us, and will always provide for us.”

In a touching conclusion, Rav Sorotzkin shared a story about meeting former Bank of Israel Governor Prof. Stanley Fischer in a Manhattan elevator. “We ended up talking for four hours. He canceled meetings. He told me he can’t understand how the Torah world survives—how chareidim are buying homes when secular Israelis only manage to do so at age forty. He asked, ‘Where did you study economics?’ I told him: ‘Hilchos To’en V’nit’an in the Rambam.’”

“As the meeting ended, he said, ‘I just don’t get how the chareidi economy works.’ I told him, ‘Then open your eyes and see—it’s all from Hashem, who sustains and provides.’”

{Matzav.com Israel}

From Matzav, here.

קדושת ציון: ראיון עם הר”ח איינהורן שליט”א

אנחנו חרדים, ארץ ישראל היא הלב שלנו, ואנחנו רוצים מדינה על פי תורה

לכנסים של הארגון החרדי “קדושת ציון” מגיעים אלפים ובכל זאת קשה לדעת כמה השיח הגאולי שהם מובילים הוא נחלת החברה החרדית. פחות מדברים על יום העצמאות, ויותר על ניסים ויום ירושלים | ריאיון

  • מנחם בן שחר
  • ב’ אב תשפ”ה – 18:32 27/07/2025

הרב חיים גר בירושלים, אברך חרדי ‘קלאסי’ וחבר הנהלת קדושת ציון, ארגון המאגד אוהבי ארץ ישראל מתוך הציבור החרדי. שאלנו אותו מה מביא אדם חרדי למהדרין לעסוק בנושאי ארץ ישראל וגאולה?

“כשלמדתי בישיבת בית מתתיהו התרחש הגירוש מגוש קטיף ומאז התחלתי להרגיש שייכות לנושאים של ‘עם ישראל’ כעם אחד. כך הבנתי שיש שקוראים לזה ‘לאומיים’. המגורים באופקים סייעו לי להבין בבירור את הסכנה הגדולה, והלכתי לעצרות תפילה גדולות שהיו לפני הגירוש, שם היה גם הרב זלמן נחמיה גולדברג זצ”ל, שלימים נישאתי לנכדתו. בהמשך השנים הייתי אחראי על רכישת הספרים באוצר הספרים של הישיבה, וקראתי הרבה ספרים של גדולי ישראל – מכתבי החזון איש, החפץ חיים, ואפילו הרב שך ועוד, ונוכחתי לדעת שיש פער בין הכתוב לבין ההשקפה המקובלת. הבנתי שישנם דברים מהותיים וחשובים בתורה, שהוכנסו לאיזו מגרה צדדית בטענה שהם לא רלוונטיים”.

איזה נושאים למשל?

האם לחיות בתפיסה, בתודעה פרטית או בתודעה של עם? האם יש לנו חלק בגאולה? האם יש לנו אחריות על הגאולה? לכך שיש משמעות אדירה ומחייבת לכך שסוף סוף אחרי אלפיים שנה חזרנו הביתה, לקשר שלנו לכל מקום ומקום בארץ הקדושה הזאת.

איך באמת קורה שנושאים חשובים כל כך נדחקים הצידה?

מה שקורה זה שיש ויכוח באמת גדול ונוקב מאוד, איך להתייחס למצב היום שהוא מצב של דיעבד גדול. שיש מדינה ויש תפיסה לאומית אבל זה בידיים של לא שומרי תורה ומצוות, המערכת לא הולכת על פי האמונה. אנחנו לא מתעסקים עם הויכוח הזה, אלא מדברים על מה צריך להיות לכתחילה, הטענה שלנו היא, שזה אמור להיות מוסכם לחלוטין.

מה הרב זלמן נחמיה אמר על קדושת ציון?

הרב היה מאוד קשוב אלינו, לשאלות והתייעצויות, וגם התראיין באריכות. הוא חזר על דבריו כמה פעמים שיש חשיבות גדולה בעיסוק הזה, ו’זו מצווה גדולה’. הרב הדריך אותנו להיזהר לא לעשות ציבור נפרד, לא להיכנס למחלוקות. ואנחנו משתדלים מאוד ללכת כהדרכתו.

   |להחליף את הקהילתיות בלאומיות של תורה

הרב חיים מספר כי הארגון החל לפעול לפני עשר שנים, בתאריך כ”ח באייר. יום ירושלים הוא היום של קדושת ציון. ציון הנס של מלחמת ששת הימים הוא יותר מקומי-עובדתי. התיישבה קבוצה של שבעה עשר אנשים, ישבו ודיברו על הנס הגדול והחליטו להוציא עלון חודשי ובו מאמרים בכיוון. לאט לאט גדלה רשימת התפוצה של כתובות דוא”ל, ובזכות תרומה של כמה אלפי שקלים החלו בהדפסת העלון וחלוקתו עד שהוא צמח לעוצמות של היום כאשר בסך הכל למעלה ממיליון גליונות מלאים בחומר איכותי על הקשר המעשי לארץ ישראל, ועל תהליך הגאולה הופצו בריכוזים החרדיים.

פעם בשנה מתקיים כינוס גדול, ביום ירושלים, וכן יש ימי סיורים, סיבובי שערים, ופעילויות במאחזים כמו הקמת פינות נוף שונות ‘רק מחוץ לגדר’, באזור גוש עציון, בנימין ושומרון. האהדה לארגון ניכרת גם בהיבט הכלכלי – מאות הוראות קבע קטנות מחזיקות את ‘קדושת ציון’ ומאפשרות את הפעילות. לכינוס האחרון הגיעו יותר מאלפיים איש מכל גווני הציבור החרדי, הפרסום לקראת הכנס נעשה בעלונים הקבועים בלבד.

אפיק פעולה נוסף של חברי ‘קדושת ציון’ – עידוד עלייה. פרסומים ופעילויות ושונות בקרב קהילות יהודים בחו”ל במטרה לעודד עלייה של יחידים או קהילות שלמות.

לכינוסים שלנו מגיעים אלפי יהודים מהציבור החרדי. אבל ההשפעה היא הרבה מעבר למי שבאים בפועל. אנחנו רואים בדיונים ויכוחים ודיבורים בישיבות, בכוללים, ובכל מקום בעצם, שזה בהחלט מתעורר. אי אפשר למחוק ולהתעלם מכך שהתורה כולה מלאה דיבורים על עם ישראל, ועל חשיבות ארץ ישראל. יש עכשיו במאה שערים גרפיטי: ‘מדינת הלכה = כפירה במלכות שמיים’. מישהו שם נבהל מהדיבורים שלנו על מה צריך לעשות עכשיו שיהיה לכתחילה.

אתם בעד לאומיות ונגד קהילתיות? אצל החרדים הקהילה חזקה.

לפעמים באמת הקהילתיות מחליפה את הלאומיות, וזה לא אמור להיות כך. היה בחור ישיבה שחזר מכינוס של קדושת ציון, וחבר מישיבת פוניבז’ עקץ אותו ‘נו, מה למדתם שם להרביץ לערבים’? והבחור ענה לו: ומה אתה למדת – להרביץ ליהודים?… כלומר, קבוצת ההתייחסות הפשוטה זה לחיות בתודעה של ‘אני יהודי, אני חלק מעם ישראל’ ולא  ‘אני אשכנזי / חסידי / ליטאי / ספרדי’.

תודעת הלאומיות שלנו היא גדולה ויש בתוכה מקום להרבה שבטים וקהילות. בקדושת ציון יש חסידי סאטמר, כל הגוונים הליטאיים, ברסלב, גור מקהילות שונות, סלונים מקהילות שונות, שסניקים עם תלמידי הרב מאזוז – אצלנו כולם ממש ביחד וזה חידוש.

   |הגאולה תלויה בשאלה אם החרדים ייקחו אחריות לאומית

אתם בעד ארץ ישראל, בעד לאומיות וקידום הגאולה, אז אולי אתם לא חרדים בכלל?

אנחנו חרדים לגמרי! וזה ניכר בדברים הבסיסיים – אין אצלנו לימוד זכות על הרשעים ונתינת לגיטימציה, או חיבור איתם, אנחנו לחלוטין בתוך החומות של הציבור החרדי, ומאמינים בזה, יש לנו רק טלפונים כשרים בלי וצפ, כי אנחנו חושבים שההכרעה החרדית בעניין יראת שמיים היא נכונה לגמרי, ובנין הקהילות, ועבודת השם. בכל זה אנחנו חרדים באופן מלא ומאמינים בזה.

אז מה היחס שלכם למדינה?

המדינה כפי שהיא היום זה לא הדיון שלנו, יש כל מיני דרכים איך להתייחס ועסקו בזה הרבה. אנחנו דנים במהות ומסתכלים  קדימה – האם צריכה להיות מדינה יהודית לפי התורה?

לכאורה זה פשוט, לא?

לא כל כך, כי להיכנס לסוגיות לאומיות זו אחריות מאוד מאוד גדולה. לכאורה יותר נח להתחמק ולהתמקד במה שרגילים אבל זה לא עובד. אמרתי לאחד הקנאים: ‘אתה נלחם נגד הרכבת כי יהיו בה נוסעים לא צנועים ברחוב בר אילן, אבל מה עם רחוב יפו? הפקרתם אותו? אם הייתם אכפתיים על יפו, אולי הייתם מצליחים להציל את בר אילן. אם אנחנו מראש ‘מודה במקצת’ ואין לנו מה לומר בסוגיה הכללית – בסוף הרוחות שנושבות בציבור הכללי יגיעו גם אלינו, ולכן עדיף לחשוב בגדול בצורה לאומית כוללת.

החרדים לדעתך מסוגלים לקחת אחריות?

בוודאי שכן. אהבת ישראל לכל יהודי זה יש בהרבה קהילות חרדיות, ומזה צריך להתקדם גם לרגש ל’עם ישראל’ מה שברחוב נקרא לפעמים לאומי, להגיע לתחושת שייכות ואחריות.

הרב איינהורן מספר על אברך מארגון קדושת ציון שהגיע לכולל שלו ביום כ”ח באייר, ובצהריים הניח ‘משקה’ ורוגלעך בפינת קפה. שאלו אותו ‘האי מאי’, לכבוד מה? וסיפר להם שקרה לו נס גדול לפני כמה שנים, נסע כדרכו לביקור בחוות בשומרון, ואז מצידי הכביש קפצו מולו כמה מחבלים חמושים, וכמעט הרגו אותו, פתאום הופיע ג’יפ צבאי והרג בהם וברחו. החברים התפלאו איך לא שמעו על הסיפור הזה עד היום. ואז גילה להם: זה לא היה רק אני, זה היה כל העם היושב בציון, וזה לא היה כמה מחבלים אלא כל הצבאות של מדינות ערב, ולא היה רק ג’יפ אחד אלא כל צה”ל. ‘נו, אז בגלל שזה כולם – פחות צריך להודות או יותר’?

מה העמדה שלכם בעניין הגיוס לצבא?

“לי ברור, כשהצבא יהיה מותאם ויהיה גיוס חרדים – החרדים ייכנסו לחשיבה לאומית והתיפקוד של צה”ל יהיה יותר נחוש בזכותם. עם ישראל צריך את הכוחות האלו, החרדים באופיים הם מאוד חדים, לא סתם הם לבושים שחור לבן, אצלם הדברים מאוד ברורים בלי בלבולים. בפועל הבחורים תומכי הארגון בדרך כלל ממשיכים ללמוד בישיבות ולא מתגייסים. כמו בכל שאר הדברים, בהתייחסות למדינה כרגע, שהיא לא לפי התורה, בזה אנחנו חרדים לגמרי”.

חברי הארגון גם לא משתייכים פוליטית לשום מפלגה, ולא ממליצים לפני בחירות במי לבחור.

מה היעדים שלכם כארגון לשנים הקרובות?

שיפסיק הדיבור הזה שאנחנו בגלות. לא, צריך לפקוח עיניים ולהודות להשם על השמירה הגדולה שלו עלינו כבר עשרות שנים פה. וכמובן הקמת עוד מקומות יישוב חלוציים חרדים. השאיפה היא שהציבור החרדי יתעורר ברמה הלאומית וינהיג ויוביל את המדינה לפי התורה וההלכה.

מאתר הקול היהודי, כאן.