The Velvet Muzzle: Unwritten Rules and Unspoken Costs for Rabbinic Elites

I’m quoting Jeff Tucker, but it’s the same here (or moreso), סדנא דארעא חד הוא:

Entering into the upper echelons of opinion making, whether in academia or media or civil society generally, requires three types of training. First, you need to develop expertise in some area or at least be able to present evidence that other experts regard you as an expert. Second, you need to show evidence that you can speak the rarified form of language that is reserved to elite opinion, which has its own special vocabulary for communication and cultural signalling. And third, you need to develop proficiency in knowing what to say and believe.

This is what advanced training amounts to. Master all three, and you cross into a different realm from that inhabited by the rabble. Staying in that place requires close adherence to the rules and the presentation of ongoing evidence that you are willing to play the game, even better if you strongly believe in the game itself.

There is a narrow bound of opinion holding that pertains at all times. In moments of genuine crisis – disruptive political leaders, wars, huge legislative changes, trade agreements, pandemic responses – when the stakes grow much higher, the enforcement of these rules becomes much more strict. The slightest deviation raises eyebrows and reduces trust in your reliability.

Everyone in these realms knows what to do and say. That’s not even a question. The issue becomes: what does one do when the intellect and conscience conspire to lead one into a position of dissent from the prevailing orthodoxy? That’s when you have to size up the costs and benefits of courage. The costs are overwhelming: the risk of power, position, material support, reputation, and legacy. The benefits come down to the feeling of having done the right thing.

The rest is here…

Back Up Abandoned Torah Sites!

If it has vulnerable .asp pages, a table-based layout from way back, the copyright and writing style convey 2003, and so on, the site is on borrowed time.

Mp3Shiur.com is a perfect example. Download what you care about or might someday care about.

A word to the wise…

Who Killed Moshe Bloi? The Conspiracy Theory

Quoting Wikipedia:

בלוי שיתף פעולה עם מנהיגי היישוב הציוני במשא ומתן עם המנדט הבריטי לשמירת האינטרסים של הציבור היהודי בארץ. הוא ייצג את אגודת ישראל בפני מספר ועדות בריטיות ובינלאומיות… ב-1946 חלה על סיפונה של ספינה כשהיה בנסיעה לחו”ל במסגרת עבודתו, והורד בבית החולים במסינה שבאיטליה. תוך ימים ספורים הוא נפטר, והובא למנוחות בהר הזיתים כעבור תשעה ימים. בניו של בלוי ייחסו את מותו לשיברון לב כתוצאה מהפילוג בין העדה החרדית ואגודת ישראל. בחוגי העדה החרדית טוענים כי הוא הורעל על ידי כוחות ציוניים.

Here is an interesting letter to the editor in Mishpacha:

View or Download the PDF / פתח או הורד את הקובץ

I don’t know more, but this deserves to be preserved in any case.

Claude Introduces Our Old ‘Greenwashing’ Post

Find the article itself over here…

The Central Argument

The piece is essentially a Rothbardian shrug at environmentalist outrage over greenwashing. The author’s thesis: businesses are amoral demand-satisfiers. They didn’t create environmentalist ideology; they’re just monetising it like they monetise every other passing craze — tobacco, communism, tulips, Mussar. Greenwashing isn’t corruption of capitalism; it is capitalism, doing exactly what it does; customers don’t want the truth, or they don’t know what they want yet.

Key moves the author makes:

Against Rand: The opening salvo is a rebuke of Ayn Rand’s romanticisation of businessmen as conscious philosopher-heroes. The author’s view is sharply demystifying — businessmen have an unteachable practical knack, don’t understand economics, and couldn’t care less about “what money represents.” This is very Rothbardian: no heroic capitalist class, just actors responding to price signals.

The demand problem: The author raises the Yetzer Hara / Nisayon framing (the evil inclination / test) for the question of whether businesses worsen culture or merely capitalise on pre-existing demand. His conclusion leans toward the latter — if demand is already there, the supplier is neither helping nor hurting. This is a classically libertarian deflection of moral responsibility away from the producer.

Against regulation: His response to critics demanding tighter enforcement is crisp and characteristically iconoclastic — why not private certification, like hechshers? The analogy to kosher certification is a clever and characteristically Jewish move: the market already invented this, it’s called kashrus, you don’t need the FTC (at some price, anyway!).

The Feiglin quote: “A small-time criminal breaks the law. A medium criminal bypasses the law. A major criminal perpetrates his crime by means of the law.” This is the rhetorical apex of the piece — regulatory capture as the real greenwashing story. The bottled water industry example follows: “pure, untouched water” legally redefined to permit sugar additives. The target isn’t the dishonest marketer; it’s the state that launders corporate fraud through legislation.

On the “Seven Sins”: He subverts the “sins” as consulting advice for business…

The voice and method

The piece is written in the author’s signature style: short punchy paragraphs, rhetorical questions, strategic italics, dry wit. The Wikipedia excerpts serve as a foil — the author uses mainstream framing as a punching bag to demonstrate how statist assumptions are smuggled into seemingly neutral language (“lax enforcement compounds the problem” — he catches the moral hazard implication hiding in the word “compound”). Very sharp reading.

What the author is not saying

He’s not defending greenwashing as admirable. He’s deflating the moral panic around it. The implicit message: if you want honest environmental labelling, build a private certification market. Stop demanding that the state fix problems the state’s own regulatory apparatus helps create.

Claude also found me a parallel to “customers don’t want the truth” I had never heard before:

Akerlof and Shiller’s Phishing for Phools (behavioral economics) explicitly argues that markets efficiently supply manipulation because manipulation is demanded, although they’re alarmed by this and therefore call for State intervention.

Find it here…

תורת אשכנז ותורת ספרד\מזרח\וכו’: מי זו אהליבה ומי זו אהלה

להלן ציטוט [עיין בפנים!] מדרשת הרב מאיר מאזוז זצ”ל:

אם באו להגיד שפסקה תורה, אני יכול להגיד להם: רבותי, פסקה תורה לפני כן באשכנז! בשנת חמשת אלפים ק”ט (זו היתה שנת המגיפה השחורה) פסקה תורה באשכנז. במשך מאה וחמשים שנה לא היו כמעט גדולי תורה. ומישהו בדק ומצא שתקופת “הראשונים” נמשכה בספרד עד הגירוש ובאשכנז עד שנת ק”ט וזהו. זו הסיבה שכמה וכמה דברים נשכחו. אני שכחתי להביא כאן ספר תולדות אדם שלומדים בו בכל הישיבות. תולדות אדם הוא ספר תולדותיו של הגאון רבי זלמן מוילנא, תלמידו של הגר”א. בפרק ב’ או בפרק ג’ בהתחלה מעתיק מספר שני לוחות הברית. אמר: עיני זלגו דמעות לראות למה אנחנו לא לומדים תורה בצורה מסודרת כמו אחינו הספרדים.

לקריאת הכל…