Well Sure, The Rabbis Hid the Evidence!

It’s hard to prove Judaism has been subverted in our time because those claims which made it most vacuous are kept out of the books. You can find such travesties as Mechiras Chametz and hair-like hair-coverings in the Poskim, but the very worst heresies are only passed on orally, like in a cult, especially to those who fall afoul of them.

This is why it’s harder to find written evidence on the regular bookshelves of Chassidic and Mussar antinomianism, the esoteric meaning of the “Chadash assur min hatorah” catchphrase, Brisker doctrines on denying reality (such as the infamous “Am Ha’aretz chicken” story) — among other things, and many more.

For a “book-based” nation, it seems strange there are important customs that somehow manage to evade a well-written exposition. Like the “holy” battles of Rabbi Shach against half of his contemporaries, Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum‘s view (adopted by other fools “in principle”) Eretz Yisrael is only for Torah scholars (Only Teshuvos Vehanahagos writes about this a bit, because he lacks the horse sense to realize this doctrine contradicts entire parshiyos in the Torah, see the parable here!).

Like the “insight” Yeshiva youth need not (and therefore ought not) observe the Torah they are busy studying (which has nothing to do with the Dinim Vehanhagos sometimes looped in on this!), hinted at throughout the “Tenu’as Hamussar” set by Rabbi Dov Katz (such as reading Shema at its proper time or covering the tables on Shabbos (which has nothing to do with eating, as they are covered on Yom Kippur, as well), or eating only truly kosher food).

Like the notion, all mitzvos are capable of observance without their numerous, peripheral “Tzitzin” of halachic “side-constraints/conditions” leading Judaism away from “legalism“.

Chazon Ish – Emunah Ubitachon, end of chapter 4:

והתמדה בדרך הדביקות מצד אחד וההזנחה בתלמודה של המצוות מצד שני, יוצרת שיטה שלמה הנראית לרבים, ומתבלטת כיצירה מסוימה, המכרזת על עצמה, ועל אלה המתיחסים אליה, כאילו אמרו חלילה הרינו מקבלים עלינו מלכות שמים ע”מ שאין עלינו דקדוק הדין.

וההכרזה הזאת הלא היא מחמורה שבחמורות, חבר הוא לפורקי עול, ולא עוד אלא שהקבלה על הדברים שהם נכנסים במחיצות קבלתו מזויפת בהחלט כאשר סיג וצרורות של המראה מעורבות בה, עירוב מכוון ומבוסס, מחושב ויסודי.

יש צורך לאיש לראות שער אשתו – משל ונמשל

הרב יצחק ברנד שליט”א מסביר מדוע חובה על האשה לנצל את ההיתר לגלות שערה בבית כדי למגר את תופעת הפאה נכרית, בבחינת “פת בסלו”.

הרב גם מתייחס לבעיית העבודה זרה שנתגלתה בפאות, כפי שהאריכו כמה מחברים לאחרונה.

את המאמר המלא ניתן למצוא כאן.

מנהג אותיות גהנ”ם – מדליקים את האש תחת המיחם בשבת ומחכים לגוי

בזמן שהותו של הג”ר ירוחם [ליבוביץ] בבריסק. הזמין חתנו [של רבי ירוחם, ה”ה] הג”ר ישראל חיים קפלן את אאמו״ר [הגראי”ל שטינמן] לביתו, ואמר לו שקשה לתאר את מצב היהדות ברוסיה. שפעם הוא היה בעיירה אחת של עמי הארצות, וראה שבשבת מדליקים את האש תחת הסמאוואר (המיחם), ומחכים לגוי, ואמרו שמנהגם לא לשתות מהמים עד שהגוי שותה. שהם לא ידעו שכל המנהג זה רק שהגוי מדליק בשביל עצמו כדי לשתות ולא שהם ידליקו, עד כדי כך היו עמי ארצות אז.

(מתוך דברי בנו רבי משה שטינמן מראשי ישיבת עטרת שלמה אריה – ירושלים בקובץ זכרון על הגראי”ל שטינמן, קובץ גליונות – קובץ רמ״ה ה׳תשע״ט, עמוד 4)

הנה הגליון:

תודה לאחד הקוראים היקרים על עזרתו. 

How Wikipedia Defines ‘Conviction Politics’

Conviction politics is the practice of campaigning based on a politician’s own fundamental values or ideas rather than attempting to represent an existing consensus or simply take positions that are popular in polls.

On the right, the term has been adopted by politicians like Margaret Thatcher, who declared, “I am not a consensus politician. I am a conviction politician” in 1979, a few months before her election as prime minister.

They mention Thatcher, but not Ron Paul?!

There are a number of arguments for conviction politics. One is that it is more honest; conviction politicians simply say what they believe rather than shading their opinions to be more palatable to their audience. Another is that by voicing strong opinions, they push the public debate forward and promote a genuine discussion of political issues. Even if the candidates lose, they will have promoted their particular political ideas and persuaded some voters of their value.

We have written about this elsewhere in connection with Moshe Feiglin’s “Zehut” party.

There are also more instrumental reasons. By arguing forcefully for their positions during the campaign, politicians are more able to pursue the goals once in office. Also, proponents argue that conviction politicians are more likely to win. When he was a candidate, Tom Perriello stated that “More often, the deepest connection with another person comes from when I disagree with them and admit it, because at least they know I will tell the truth. While some strategists focus on positioning candidates on issue after issue, I believe most voters focus more on whether the candidate integrity and character on the whole, demonstrated by the conviction to take a stand.”

US politician Senator Paul Wellstone, for example, frequently heard voters tell him, “I don’t always agree with you, but I like it that I know where you stand.” He found that when he announced his opposition to the 2003 invasion of Iraq, an unpopular position at the time, he jumped to a five-point lead in the polls.

In the United States, 87% of voters in one poll said they think politicians are “pretty much willing to say whatever it takes in order to get themselves elected.” By saying what they believe and ignoring the polls, conviction politicians distinguish themselves from other politicians.

So, honesty is the best policy, eh?

See the rest of Wikipedia’s article here.