Rabbi Meir Kahane: Talk to them, but tell them no. Quote 1:
“On Yo-Yoism”
Jewish Press, February 3, 1978
Let us stop the nonsense of: We will not talk to the PLO but only to other “Palestinians.” What madness! To begin with, such talk legitimizes the concept of “Palestinians” when it is imperative to cry out that there is no such concept, that there is no “Palestine” or “Palestinian” people. For if there is indeed a “Palestine” people, surely they have a right to a state of their own. The PLO is no more dangerous than Assad of Syria with whom Begin is willing to meet, and indeed, the Syrians are a great deal more dangerous with their tanks and MIG-25s. The PLO is no more dangerous and desirous of throttling Israel than any of the other Arabs of East Jerusalem or Shchem and Hebron. And end to the differentiation which only puts us into a dangerous trap. Let us place all the Arabs in the same role: that of wanting, through different measures and tactics, to put an end to Israel. There is nothing wrong with sitting with all of them, including the PLO, and saying: NO
Quote 2 implies the same, but moves a bit further:
“On Jews and Judaism” May 25, 1979
“Palestine” and Autonomy
“Woe unto them that call evil good and good evil” (Isaiah 5:20)
“Hear, ye deaf, and look, ye blind, that ye may see” (Isaiah 42:18
Prime Minister Begin has been adamant in stating that there will “never be a Palestine state” and “we will never speak with the PLO.” Yet in the Camp David accords, Mr. Begin agreed to the following:
“Egypt, Israel, Jordan and the representatives of the Palestine people should participate in negotiations on the resolution of the Palestinian problem in all its aspect.” And again: “The solution from the negotiations must also recognize the legitimate rights of the Palestinian people and their just requirements.”
The “Palestine” people. For decades, Israeli leaders were careful never to speak of or recognize a “Palestine people.” For if there exists a “Palestine people” what is a more just requirement and a legitimate right than a state of their own? What is the most basic right of any people if not the right to its own state? How can we speak of a “Palestine people” and then say “but they cannot have their own state!”
And if we speak of the “representative of the Palestine people,” what will be if these “people” choose as their representatives, the PLO? And any Israeli leader who tells us that the majority of the “Palestinians” do not accept the PLO as their leaders, lies to us, and proof is his for the asking by simply allowing free elections in which the PLO is allowed to participate. Indeed, there is ludicrousness in the repeated pledges against speaking with the PLO even as there is daily contact and cooperation with the PLO mayors of Hebron, Ramallah, Sh’chem and other towns!
When Begin signed an accord which had as its official English translation the concept of a “Palestine people” and its “legitimate and basic rights,” he set the stage for a confrontation with the entire world, a confrontation which is of his own making. Instead of having cleaved to a staunch, open and honest disclaimer of any “Palestine people,” he, for the countless time, chose the path of deviousness by which he signed an accord that speaks of a “Palestine people” and then stated in a letter to Carter that he construes “Palestine people” to mean “Palestinian Arabs.” It is, once again, the tortured legalism that Begin uses so often to evade confrontation but which is so meaningless to the world. The official version speaks of a “Palestine people” and its legitimate rights, the most basic of which is clearly the right to the same kind of state that Jewish have.
…
Quote 3 (very entertaining exchanges, by the way, see there!):
Official Knesset transcript, July 31, 1985:
לדבר עם אש”ף? להשמיד את אש”ף. לדבר עם נאצים? עם כהנא אסור לדבר; עם אש”ף חייבים. צבועים שכמותכם. את השונא מצווה לשנוא. צריך להבין את הפסוק בקוהלת האומר: “עת לאהב ועת לשנא. עת מלחמה ועת שלום”. את אש”ף מצווה לשנוא. עת לשנוא, מלחמה עד תורמה בו. אדם שלא ישנא את האויב, יאפשר לו להשמיד אותו. אלה שהולכים להיפגש אתם. פלד. מיעארי, הראל, אבנרי ושאר מדברים עם אש”ף? השרצים, הם בוגדים במובן המלא של המלה. היהדות התורה היא נר לעם ישראל. היא מדריכה אותנו איך להתנהג עם אש”ף .עם שונאי ישראל… נוקמים נקמת דם ישראל מאש”ף… לא מדברים עם אש״ף. משמידים את אש״ף.
He seems to change his mind here, but in context he is not opposing talks per se, but preferring action. I found an interview where he again says the same thing in 1988 (in here somewhere): sit down, but tell them no. As I recall, some of his followers were surprised at his view.
Ah, but then here is the son, who omits mentioning his father, Rabbi Binyamin Zev Kahane, “Sometimes It’s Good to Be Deaf” (1997).
Quoting the main part:
…
A question must be asked here: Why, of all people, was it the grandson Hushim ben Dan who reacted this way? Why was he shocked at was happening? Why did he arise to wipe out the reproach? Did not the rest of the sons care about Yaakov’s honor? Where was Yehuda, or the zealots Shimon and Levy, for example?
From here, we learn an awesome lesson, which is especially related to matters of national honor and Kiddush Hashem. The difference between Hushim ben Dan and the rest of the sons of Yaakov was that Hushim was the only one who was not involved in the negotiations with Esau. Psychologically, the moment you hear out the other party and weigh his point of view, even the most outrageous claim begins to be “understood”. The very discussing of it desensitizes you, and gets you used to the idea.
Without a doubt, if someone were to tell the sons of Yaakov beforehand that Esau is waiting for them in the Cave of the Patriarchs to thwart the burial of their father, they would boil over with holy rage, assured that they know how to deal with the situation.
But what happened was that the moment they arrived, Esau stated his case: “It’s mine.” Sure, the sons of Yaakov were shocked and angry, but it is human nature not to want to leave an argument or claim unanswered, without an appropriate rebuttal. And so, they reminded him that he sold it. Esau immediately countered: ‘I only sold the birthright, not the grave,’ etc. At this point, too, the brothers know that Esau is wrong, but in any case, he makes an argument that demands some kind of answer. And most important of all: at this stage, the sons of Yaakov find themselves in the heat of a negotiation process.An onlooker from the side can easily get the impression that both sides make reasonable claims. They would certainly have great difficulty realizing that what we have here is a scoundrel whose entire goal is to degrade Yaakov.
In contrast, the deaf Hushim ben Dan cannot hear all the claims. He knows only one thing: “Grandfather is lying here in disrespect!” Sure, Yaakov’s sons knew exactly what kind of derelict, cheater and murderer Esau was. But because they entered into negotiations with him, they began to think that perhaps he is sincere this time, and said to themselves: ‘All we need to do is to convince him that we are right, and everything will be okay.’ But Hushim did not have the opportunity to become “convinced” of the justice of Esau’s wicked and bogus claims, and he did not understand how his brothers allowed this low-life to delay, even for a moment, the burial of Yaakov, the father of our nation. And so, he arose and took action!
Sometimes, it is forbidden to negotiate. What’s so bad about it? After all, you are only talking. But no. For even if you know that your “partner” is a liar with evil intentions, you begin to “understand” him and think there might be “something to what he is saying,” after all.
Of course, he is echoing/copying the famous Sichos Mussar by R’ Chaim Shmuelevitz, published in stencil 1972 (תשל”ב). The specific Chushim shmuess comes from an Elul talk given on Nitzavim 5731, which means 1971 (although he mentioned the idea a year prior).
