The Abortive ‘Medinat Yehuda’ Plan: A History

Medinat Yehuda : Palestine or Judea???

18 August 2013

13 Elul 5773

In January 1989, Rabbi Meir Kahane, Hy”d, held a conference about which he said, “We did not declare a state.  We declared our intent to declare a state if and when Israel will leave the areas.” [Yehuda, Shomron and Aza – Yesha]

To the government of the State of Israel, he said:

“You will not be able to sign an accord with the Palestinians giving up parts of the Land of Israel – you will not be able to.  This is not Sinai, this is not Yamit.  Here, we’re not dealing with two or three thousand people. Here, you are speaking of 65,000 settlers who live there, including 100,000 Jews who live right across the border who will pour into the area to ensure that it will not be given up because they know that the day after a Palestinian state arises in Judea and Samaria, the next day, the Palestinians will say, “now to the next.”

It’s clear that while Rabbi Meir Kahane put no faith in the Israeli government, he put a lot of faith in his fellow Jews.

Twenty-four years later, we’re not still talking about 65,000 settlers.  We’re talking about 350,000 settlers. And today, we are no longer talking about 100,000 Jews living on the Green Line, but the entire population of 7.5 million who are in rocket range!  And even so, still the government is continuing with the same insane and unfeasible policies.

Why? Well, maybe the government knows something today that Rabbi Meir Kahane did not know in 1989. For one thing, no replacement has ever been found for Rabbi Meir Kahane since the US and Israeli governments colluded to silence him permanently in November of 1990.

Second, Rabbi Kahane was speaking in a time before the Madrid Conference and before Oslo took it’s terrible twenty-years of terrorism toll; before the US and Israeli governments colluded to train and arm a Palestinian-Arab army on our doorstep. And before the US Ambassador to the UN suggested quite openly that the US introduce a “massive protection force” to impose a solution on the parties.

Third, Rabbi Kahane did not live to witness the ease with which 8600 Jews were forcibly expelled from Gush Katif, along with the complete and utter destruction of seventeen Jewish communities, including the removal of graves.

האם יש מצוה למנות מלך או לא? – מצאתי חבר לפירושי

אני רגיל לפרש שיש מצוה רק אם רצו, כעין פי’ הנצי”ב.

כעת מצאתי שכ”כ גם הרב רפאל בירודוגו בספר “מי מנוחות” עה”ת, עמ’ 258-260.


אגב, יש ללמוד מתוך דבריו שם לכבד גם מי ששוגה מאד מאד רח”ל (וכמו שכבר הבאנו מפי’ המלבי”ם עם הרב אברבנאל בענין דומה), וז”ל:

אך רע עלי מאד מה שסיים הרב שם וכתב אין להקשות ממא’ הכתוב בפשע ארץ רבבים שריה כי שם מהשרים דבר לא מהמנהיגים והשופטים. וגם כי שהע”ה בענין המלכים לעצמו היה דורש עכ”ל. וכ”כ עוד בפי’ למלכים תצל אוזן שומעת שחשב לספרי הקדש כספרי החכמות ושלח ידו במשיח ה’ שדרש לעצמו מה שאינו אמת חלילה ומעולם לא נשמע כזה משום חכם ואפי’ מחכמי התלמוד, ואפי’ התנאים לא יוכלו לו’ דבר זה כי כל דבריו ע”ה ברוה”ק נאמרו והחולק עליהם כחולק על השכינה. אבל חנם חלק על הכתוב… שארי ליה מאריה.

I Was Blown Away by Hearing Rabbi Shnayor Burton on His Sefer ‘HaAretz Asher Arecha’!

With Rav Shnayor Burton discussing the mitzvah to reside in Eretz Yisrael and his new Sefer on the topic

#196.

** To support the podcast: https://seforimchatter.com/support-seforimchatter/ or email seforimchatter@gmail.com**

With Rav Shnayor Burton discussing the mitzvah to reside in Eretz Yisrael and his new Sefer HaAretz Asher Arecha on the topic.

We discussed why he decided to write a sefer on the topic, what the sefer is not, what he is trying to accomplish with the sefer, who the sefer is geared towards, an overview of the mitzvah, the Satmar Rav’s shitah and Rav Burton’s response, sources used, haskamos, and much more

To purchase the Sefer: https://www.ebay.com/itm/374477700772

For Rav Burton’s podcast series on the topic: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-great-sources-with-rabbi-shnayor-burton/id1493232233

To email Rav Burton: oros.yaakov@gmail.com

For Rav Burton’s substack: https://shnayor.substack.com/

From SeforimChatter, here.