Chanuka: ‘Who, Whom’?

The Politically-Incorrect But True Story Of Hanukkah

 Erev Shabbath Qodesh Parashath Wayeshev/Hanukkah 5770

In a nutshell, here is the prelude to the valiant war fought by the Hashmonaim (Makkabim) about 2,165 years ago:

The powers that be at the time offered “the honor” of performing an act of avodah zarah to Mattithiyahu ben Yohanan, the High Priest.

He refused.

The powers that be offered it to another, who accepted.

However, before he had a change to perform this act of avodah zarah, he was killed by Mattithiyahu.

As one could imagine, the powers that be were not at all thrilled the prospect of having their authority threatened. Sound familiar?

And so, Mattithiyahu, his sons, and increasing number of followers retreated, plotted and planned, and fought on of the most spiritually important wars, Israel has ever fought. Well, they were all important.

But who was it that they fought?

Do most Jews, inside or outside of Israel, even know the answer to this question?

Examples of attempted answers to this question include:

1. Syrians
2. Greeks
3. Syrian Greeks
4. Selucid Greeks

How about Jews? That’s right. Jews. Jews were among those the Hashmonaim fought and killed.

Assimilated, Hellenized Jews.

“Oh, but that was then; this is now.” (Huh?)

“No, the Westernized Jews of today have a different status now.” (Why?)

“No, you don’t understand. There aren’t really any rasha’im (evil people) today. It’s not their fault. We have to show them, and bring them back to Torah.” (Even though the Gemara says otherwise. Uncensored Rav A. Y. says otherwise as well.)

And these responses are coming from religious Jews! I do not even have to complicate matters by listing some of the responses from the non-religious, or so-called “liberal” ones!

Now, I am by no means, suggesting the we go around killing people that we don’t like, let alone try to sort out all who I think is evil or who you think is evil.

Continue reading
From Esser Agaroth, here.

Comments are closed, but trackbacks and pingbacks are open.